Social media can transform how nonprofits connect with supporters, raise funds, and share their mission. In 2025, platforms like Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and TikTok allow even small organizations to engage directly with donors, volunteers, and partners without massive budgets. By setting clear goals, understanding your audience, and using AI tools to streamline content creation, nonprofits can maximize their impact online.

Key Takeaways:

• Set measurable goals tied to your mission (e.g., increasing donations or volunteer sign-ups).

• Identify your audience and their platform preferences (e.g., younger supporters on TikTok, professionals on LinkedIn).

• Focus on visual storytelling and personal stories to connect emotionally.

• Use AI tools to save time on content creation and scheduling.

• Regularly track metrics (engagement, website traffic, conversions) to refine your approach.

Quick Overview:

1. Define goals and audience.

2. Choose platforms based on audience behavior.

3. Plan content using a calendar and focus on engaging visuals.

4. Leverage AI for faster, more efficient workflows.

5. Measure results to improve performance.

This guide equips nonprofits to build a social media presence that drives real-world results while staying efficient and focused on their mission.

How to Plan Your Nonprofit's Social Media Strategy (using content pillars) #nonprofitmarketing

Step 1: Set Goals and Find Your Audience

Every successful social media strategy begins with a clear roadmap: knowing what you want to achieve and understanding who you need to reach. These two elements shape everything, from platform selection to the type of content you’ll share. Start by defining your goals and identifying the audiences that will help you meet them.

Define Clear, Measurable Goals

Your social media goals should align with your nonprofit’s mission, going beyond surface-level metrics like gaining followers. Instead, focus on outcomes that truly advance your organization’s impact.

Using the SMART framework - Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound - can help you set actionable goals. For example, you might aim to increase email sign-ups, secure more volunteer applications, boost donation conversions, or drive event registrations. These metrics directly tie to your mission and provide a meaningful way to measure success.

Different nonprofits have different priorities. Advocacy groups might aim for growing petition signatures, service organizations may focus on recruiting volunteers, and fundraising efforts often center on increasing donations. It’s also helpful to set a mix of short-term and long-term goals. Short-term objectives could include promoting an upcoming event or launching a new campaign, while long-term goals might involve building your organization’s reputation or becoming a trusted voice in your area of focus. These goals not only guide your strategy but also help you prioritize the right audience segments.

Identify and Understand Your Audience

With your goals in place, the next step is to connect them to your audience. Different groups of supporters have unique motivations, communication preferences, and platform habits. For example, donors often look for transparency and evidence of impact, volunteers seek meaningful ways to contribute, beneficiaries need accessible information about services, and community partners value collaboration opportunities.

Develop detailed audience personas to better understand these groups. Include basic demographics like age, location, and income, but also dig deeper into their values, motivations, and online behaviors. This level of detail helps you craft messaging that resonates.

Know where your audience spends time online. Younger supporters may gravitate toward Instagram and TikTok, while older donors might prefer Facebook and LinkedIn. Professional partners and grant-makers often rely on LinkedIn for networking and updates. By identifying these preferences, you can focus your efforts on the platforms that matter most.

Analyze your current supporters to spot patterns. Look at your donor database, volunteer lists, or email subscribers to uncover common traits and interests. This data can guide you in reaching similar audiences.

Timing and context are key. Working professionals might check LinkedIn during their morning commute or lunch break, while parents may browse Facebook in the evening. Students often scroll through Instagram or TikTok between classes. Knowing when and how your audience engages can make your outreach more effective.

Tailor your tone and messaging to suit each group. Corporate sponsors might respond better to formal, data-driven updates, while individual donors and volunteers may connect more with personal stories or behind-the-scenes glimpses of your work. Adjusting your approach ensures your communication feels relevant and engaging to each audience segment.

Step 2: Choose the Right Platforms for Your Nonprofit

Once you've nailed down your goals and identified your audience, the next step is selecting the best platforms to connect with them. Each social media platform has its own strengths, caters to specific audience groups, and supports different types of content. Instead of spreading yourself too thin by trying to be everywhere, focus on the platforms where your audience is most active and engaged.

Compare Popular Social Media Platforms

Each platform offers unique opportunities to connect with your supporters and share your mission. Here's a breakdown of what they bring to the table:

Facebook is a powerhouse for building communities and running fundraising campaigns. Its features - like groups, events, detailed posts, and targeted ads - make it a great choice for fostering discussions, sharing updates about your initiatives, and engaging diverse audiences.

Instagram shines when it comes to visual storytelling. With its focus on high-quality images, short videos, and Stories, it’s a compelling way to engage younger audiences. Tools like donation stickers and fundraising features make it easy to highlight your impact through volunteer stories or beneficiary updates.

LinkedIn is the go-to platform for professional networking. It’s perfect for connecting with corporate sponsors, board members, and grant makers. Use it to share impact reports, partnership announcements, or thought leadership pieces to enhance your credibility.

TikTok offers a creative way to connect with younger audiences through short, authentic videos. Whether it’s educational content or awareness campaigns, TikTok allows you to share the human side of your cause in a fun and engaging format.

Twitter (X) thrives on real-time updates and advocacy efforts. It’s particularly effective for nonprofits involved in policy discussions or crisis response, as it helps you join broader conversations and amplify your message.

By understanding the strengths of each platform, you can use them together to extend your reach and impact.

Use Multiple Platforms to Expand Reach

A strategic multi-platform approach allows you to connect with different audience segments while staying efficient. The trick is to repurpose content instead of creating brand-new material for every platform. For example, a detailed post about a recent fundraiser can be transformed into an Instagram slideshow, a professional update on LinkedIn, and a short, engaging TikTok video.

Start with one primary platform as your content hub, then adapt its content for secondary platforms. Keep your messaging consistent, but adjust the tone and format to fit the style of each platform. This way, you can maintain a steady content flow without overloading your team.

Take advantage of each platform’s unique tools to boost engagement. Track performance across platforms to see what’s working and refine your strategy as you go. This focused approach ensures you’re making the most of your resources while reaching your audience effectively.

Step 3: Plan and Create Content That Works

Once you've defined your goals and pinpointed your audience, the next step is crafting content that truly connects. Successful nonprofits approach content creation with a clear strategy, ensuring their messaging stays consistent, their audience remains engaged, and their mission shines through. A well-thought-out plan helps amplify your cause across platforms and keeps your efforts focused.

Build a Content Calendar

A content calendar acts as your guide for maintaining a steady, impactful presence on social media. It allows you to plan campaigns around key milestones, align messaging across channels, and avoid last-minute scrambles to create content.

Start by identifying important dates relevant to your mission. These could include awareness months, fundraising initiatives, volunteer appreciation days, or major holidays. For instance, an environmental nonprofit might center campaigns around Earth Day, World Wildlife Day, or National Recycling Week. Mark these dates on your calendar and work backward to develop supporting content that builds anticipation and engagement.

To stay organized, outline details like key dates, content formats, and posting schedules for each platform. A simple spreadsheet with columns for dates, platforms, content types, captions, hashtags, and visuals can help your team stay on track and ensure no detail is overlooked.

"Copy.ai has been phenomenal in transforming the way we develop marketing content. By automating workflows that would typically take weeks and cost thousands of dollars through agencies, they've saved us $16 million dollars this year alone." – Roman Olney, Head of Global Digital Experience @ Lenovo [1]

Batch-producing content helps maintain consistency and saves time. Scheduling tools like Hootsuite, Buffer, or Later can automate posts, ensuring they go live at optimal times - even when your team is unavailable. Incorporating AI-powered tools into your workflow can further streamline the process, ensuring every post aligns with your goals while saving precious resources.

Use Stories and Visual Content

With your content schedule in place, focus on enhancing your posts with impactful visuals and heartfelt stories. Stories are central to nonprofit marketing - they show the "why" behind your mission and help your audience see the real-world difference their support makes. Whether it's a beneficiary's inspiring journey, a volunteer's dedication, or tangible campaign outcomes, sharing these moments fosters genuine connections.

Testimonials and personal success stories bring authenticity to your messaging. When someone shares how your organization has positively impacted their life, it resonates far more than a traditional promotional post.

Visuals are equally powerful. Photos and videos tend to outperform text-only posts by grabbing attention and encouraging interaction. Use real, relatable imagery such as candid shots of volunteers, behind-the-scenes glimpses of your events, or before-and-after photos showcasing your work's impact. These visuals create a sense of authenticity and relatability.

Even with a limited budget, you can produce effective visuals. Smartphone photography, when done thoughtfully, can deliver excellent results. Focus on clear, well-lit, and natural images rather than overly polished or staged photos. Short, unpolished videos shot on a phone can also drive engagement because they feel personal and genuine.

Consistency is essential. Make sure your tone, messaging, and visual style are cohesive across all platforms so your audience immediately recognizes your organization’s voice. Encourage supporters to contribute user-generated content, like photos and stories shared with a branded hashtag. This not only broadens your reach but also builds a sense of community around your cause.

Step 4: Automate Social Media Workflows with AI

Running social media for a nonprofit can often feel like a juggling act, especially when you're working with a small team and limited funds. AI-powered tools can take over repetitive tasks, giving your team more time to focus on what really matters - connecting with supporters and driving your mission forward. By automating workflows and simplifying content creation, you can keep your social media presence active and engaging without exhausting your team or stretching resources too far. This approach also paves the way for quicker content creation, a topic we’ll dive into next.

Speed Up Content Creation with AI

Crafting compelling social media content doesn’t have to be a time sink. With AI platforms, you can generate posts, captions, and campaign ideas in a matter of seconds - far faster than traditional methods that might take days or even weeks. These tools are designed to learn your nonprofit’s voice and goals, ensuring every piece of content feels aligned with your mission and resonates with your audience.

Most AI tools allow you to set specific parameters for tone, messaging, and style, so whether you’re posting on Facebook or LinkedIn, your content remains consistent and genuine. By providing the AI with examples of your top-performing content and clear details about your audience, you can create posts that feel personalized and impactful. Plus, AI excels at producing multiple variations of a single message, giving you the flexibility to test different approaches across platforms.

Some platforms, like Averi AI, take this efficiency to the next level by combining AI-driven content generation with human input when needed. Their integrated workspace allows you to brainstorm campaigns, create posts, and even collaborate with professional marketers - all in one place. This eliminates the hassle of switching between tools and ensures your messaging stays cohesive and aligned with your mission. It’s a streamlined way to manage your social media efforts without losing sight of your goals.

Step 5: Measure Results and Improve Your Strategy

Once you've planned and shared your content, the next step is to evaluate its performance. Measuring results is crucial for refining your nonprofit's social media strategy. Posting is just the beginning - tracking how your content performs helps you engage supporters, boost donations, and expand your impact.

Track Key Performance Metrics

Understanding your audience's response begins with monitoring the right metrics:

• Engagement metrics: These include likes, comments, shares, and saves. High engagement means your content is striking a chord, driving awareness, and encouraging action toward your cause.

• Follower growth: While follower count isn’t the ultimate goal, steady growth shows that more people are discovering and staying connected to your mission.

• Website traffic from social media: Use tools like Google Analytics to track how social posts direct visitors to your site. Setting up UTM parameters helps you pinpoint which platforms and posts are driving traffic to donation pages, volunteer forms, or event sign-ups.

• Conversion metrics: These are especially critical for nonprofits. Track how many social visitors take meaningful actions, such as subscribing to your newsletter, attending events, volunteering, or donating. This data reveals the true impact of your social media efforts.

Most social platforms offer built-in analytics tools - Facebook Insights, Instagram Analytics, and LinkedIn Page Analytics are just a few examples. For deeper insights, Google Analytics is invaluable for tracking website conversions. Set specific goals, such as newsletter sign-ups or completed donations, to measure the effectiveness of your campaigns.

Adjust Strategy Based on Data

Reviewing your metrics regularly - ideally every month - helps you identify areas for improvement. Look at your top-performing posts from the past month and analyze what made them successful. Did personal stories outperform data-driven posts? Are videos generating more interaction than photos? Pinpointing these trends allows you to refine your strategy.

• A/B testing: Experiment with different posting times, captions, hashtags, and calls-to-action to see what resonates most. For instance, you could post the same content at different times, like 9 AM versus 7 PM, to determine when your audience is most active.

• Tailor content by platform: Each platform has its strengths. You might find that LinkedIn is ideal for attracting volunteers, while Instagram drives smaller donations. Use these insights to craft platform-specific content.

• Address engagement drops quickly: If you notice a sudden decrease in engagement, investigate immediately. It could be due to algorithm changes, audience fatigue with certain content, or external factors affecting your community. Tools like Averi AI can analyze performance data and streamline your workflow, helping you quickly adapt your strategy.

Seasonal trends also play a role. Document patterns in engagement throughout the year and conduct quarterly reviews to ensure your social media efforts align with your nonprofit’s larger goals. Use the data to adjust your content mix, posting schedule, and platform priorities to better meet your audience’s evolving preferences.

Conclusion: Building a Social Media Strategy That Lasts

Creating a lasting social media strategy for a nonprofit takes thoughtful planning, consistent execution, and a willingness to adapt based on real results. It’s about aligning your efforts with your mission and audience to ensure your message truly resonates.

Start with clear, measurable goals. Knowing your audience - their age, interests, and favorite platforms - helps ensure your content reaches the people who matter most to your cause. With this foundation, you can focus on what really works. Instead of trying to be everywhere, prioritize two or three platforms where your audience is most active. A well-organized content calendar can help you stay consistent, whether you're sharing donor stories, volunteer highlights, or calls-to-action.

For nonprofits with limited resources, AI-powered tools can be a game-changer. Platforms like Averi AI simplify the process by taking you from strategy to content creation and execution in one place. This kind of automation lets your team focus on building relationships and advancing your mission instead of getting stuck in the weeds of content logistics.

Regularly reviewing your data is key to improving your approach. Engagement metrics, website traffic, and conversion rates can show you what’s working and what’s not. Use these insights to experiment with new content formats, tweak your posting schedule, and refine your messaging to better connect with your audience.

The most successful nonprofits treat social media as a tool for building long-term relationships, not just a quick way to fundraise. By staying true to your brand voice, offering meaningful value to your community, and evolving based on performance data, you can create a social media presence that amplifies your mission and forges lasting connections with supporters who genuinely care about your cause. This approach ensures your efforts on social media will have a lasting impact.

FAQs

How can nonprofits track and evaluate the success of their social media strategies?

Nonprofits can evaluate how well their social media efforts are working by focusing on key performance indicators (KPIs) that align with their specific goals. Metrics such as audience engagement - measured by likes, comments, and shares - can provide a snapshot of how well content connects with followers. Other valuable indicators include tracking website traffic driven by social platforms and monitoring follower growth over time. For campaigns with targeted objectives, metrics like sign-ups, donations, or event registrations offer a clear measure of success.

To dig deeper, nonprofits can leverage analytics tools built into platforms like Facebook Insights, Instagram Analytics, or LinkedIn Analytics. These tools help uncover trends, shed light on audience behavior, and evaluate which types of content perform best. Third-party tools like Averi AI can further simplify reporting and streamline workflow management, saving time and effort.

By regularly reviewing and analyzing these metrics, nonprofits can fine-tune their strategies, focus on content that resonates most with their audience, and make the most of their resources to achieve greater impact.

What AI tools can nonprofits use to simplify social media content creation?

Nonprofits can tap into the capabilities of Averi AI, a tool crafted to simplify the often time-consuming process of creating social media content. By blending the efficiency of artificial intelligence with human insight, Averi AI enables organizations to plan, draft, and execute campaigns with ease.

Its features include automated content creation, insights into audience targeting, and tools for managing workflows. These functionalities allow nonprofits to save valuable time while delivering impactful, mission-driven content. For organizations aiming to make the most of platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn without straining their resources, Averi AI provides a practical and effective solution.

How can a nonprofit choose the right social media platforms for their strategy?

To select the best social media platforms for your nonprofit, start by pinpointing your target audience and understanding their online habits. Take into account factors like age, interests, and how they engage with content. For example, platforms like Instagram or TikTok are popular with younger demographics, while LinkedIn tends to attract professionals.

Next, match your platform choices to your nonprofit's objectives. If your focus is on sharing visual stories or behind-the-scenes updates, Instagram or Facebook could be great options. For networking or establishing expertise, LinkedIn might be a better fit. It’s important not to overextend your resources - concentrate on 2–3 platforms that align best with your mission and audience.

Lastly, consider your team’s capacity and the tools at your disposal. Some platforms demand frequent updates and creative content, so it’s crucial to ensure you can maintain a steady presence. Tools like Averi AI can assist in streamlining content creation, helping you stay consistent and efficient.

Related Blog Posts

• AI Marketing for Nonprofit

• How to Run TikTok Ads for Nonprofits

• How to Use Influencer Marketing for Nonprofits

• How to Match with the Right Marketing Experts for Nonprofits